A provincial inspection of Calgary's water utility has found that five of nine priority recommendations from a 2015–16 external review were never presented to city council, while capital spending repeatedly fell short of approved budgets in the years preceding the Bearspaw South Feeder Main failures.
The 125-page report, prepared by independent inspector David Goldie and made public November 5, identifies longstanding weaknesses in governance, infrastructure risk management, accountability and the City's ability to complete planned capital projects. The inspection makes 20 recommendations.
Five recommendations did not reach council
The City commissioned Raftelis Financial Consultants to review its water utility in 2015–16. Goldie's inspection found that five of the nine priority recommendations, including proposals for clearer financial accountability and independent expert governance, were consciously excluded from the material subsequently given to council.
The report says senior administration could disagree with a consultant's proposals, but should not have prevented elected officials from considering significant governance choices. Goldie described the handling of the earlier review as improper.
The inspection found that former mayor Naheed Nenshi and his chief of staff were part of an advance briefing and consultation process and were sent a draft-final version of the review. However, it expressly says the evidence does not establish that Nenshi directed or knowingly approved the omissions.
Nenshi, now leader of Alberta's Opposition NDP, has denied wrongdoing and criticized the provincial government's political framing of the report. The inspection's findings should not be read as a determination that he personally ordered the recommendations withheld.
Capital work repeatedly fell below budget
From 2006 to 2024, the water utility's actual capital expenditures averaged approximately 35 per cent below approved budgets. The inspector identified persistent difficulty delivering projects, rather than a simple lack of approved capital, as a central problem.
That figure measures the difference between planned and completed capital spending. It does not mean that 35 per cent of utility money was missing or diverted. The report concludes the sustained delivery gap increased long-term infrastructure risks and likely contributed to deterioration, but it does not establish that spending every approved dollar would have prevented the feeder main failures.
Goldie also found that earlier reviews and risk assessments identified concerns relevant to the feeder main, yet the City did not consistently translate those warnings into timely inspections, funded corrective work, clear risk-acceptance decisions or accountable delivery plans.
Why the findings matter to Calgarians
The Bearspaw South Feeder Main carries treated water from the Bearspaw Water Treatment Plant into Calgary's distribution network. Major failures on June 5, 2024, and December 30, 2025, disrupted water service and prompted emergency restrictions across Calgary and neighbouring communities.
The inspection argues that the problem extended beyond the condition of one pipe. Council received budgets, service plans and risk information, but did not consistently receive a joined-up assessment of infrastructure condition, reliability, deferred work and the consequences of delay.
The wider water utility, which includes drinking water, wastewater and stormwater systems, manages assets with an estimated replacement value of approximately $89.6 billion, according to the report.
What the inspector recommends
Goldie's 20 recommendations call for clearer council oversight of significant utility decisions, stronger tracking of high-risk assets, independent technical and financial review, improved reporting when planned capital work falls behind, and measurable accountability for completing reforms.
The report also recommends evaluating an arm's-length, city-controlled corporate model for the water utility, potentially involving municipally owned ENMAX, subject to detailed assessment. No such transfer has been approved as a result of this inspection.
The City has already established a Water Utility Oversight Board and appointed an acting chief operating officer. The inspector acknowledges those steps while emphasizing that their effectiveness will depend on measurable improvements.
What happens next
Alberta Municipal Affairs Minister Dan Williams says he will review the inspection and determine whether any provincial directives are warranted. The release of the report does not itself impose new directives or transfer responsibility for the water utility away from Calgary.
Mayor Jeromy Farkas has welcomed recommendations that align with reforms already underway. The City will still need to demonstrate how its current changes address the inspector's specific concerns about incomplete reporting, delayed capital work and risk oversight.
Sources and records
Government of Alberta, November 5, 2026: Calgary inspection report released.
David Goldie, final independent municipal inspection report, October 8, 2026, released November 5.
City of Calgary: Bearspaw South Feeder Main Independent Review and water transformation background.
Additional response reporting: LiveWire Calgary, November 5, 2026.

